We make our pies from scratch in house to bring you the freshest, most delicious experience possible. Our delightful gourmet flavours are offered throughout the year according to seasonality.

Enjoy our 9″ Family Pies with a crowd or our 4″ Cutie Pies on your own or with a friend.

Each week, our pies become available for walk-in customers on Thursday afternoons and remain available until Sunday afternoons, while quantities last. To ensure we have the size and quantity of pie you need, it is best to place an order in advance.

If you need pies on a Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday, a special order is required and an order minimum will apply. Please contact us for details. Don’t forget to ask for your Cupid’s Pie Loyalty card!

Now Available

Coconut Cream Pie

Coconut pastry cream nestled under luscious whipped cream, topped with a sprinkling of toasted coconut.

In Season: Sep, Oct, Nov, Dec

In Season NOW! Click to order

Cranberry Apple Snowflake Pie

Sweet apples and tart cranberries in a flaky crust, adorned with festive pastry snowflakes.

In Season: Nov, Dec

In Season NOW! Click to order

Seasonal Flavors

Blueberry Pie

Antioxidant rich blueberries enhanced with a touch of lemon zest fill a classic flaky pastry crust.

Available in 9″ only

In Season: May, Jun

In Season NOW! Click to order

Pumpkin Pie

Creamy spiced pumpkin filling in a ginger graham crust.

In Season: Thanksgiving weekend only

Dreamy Lemon Meringue

Homemade tart and tangy lemon filling in a perfect sugar cookie crust, topped with a hand-torched silky smooth meringue.

In Season: Jan, Feb

Banana Pudding Pie

Slices of fresh banana nestled within our homemade vanilla bean pudding in a sugar cookie crust, topped with vanilla bean Chantilly cream rosettes.

In Season: Jan, Feb, Mar, Apr

Irish Mudslide

An Irish Cream-spiked chocolate mousse filling, punched up with cheesecake-like richness, in a chocolate cookie crust topped with chocolate ganache and salted caramel drizzles.

In Season: Mar, Apr

Key Lime Pie

Refreshingly light and tart key lime filling in a homemade honey graham and coconut crust.

In Season: May, Jun, Jul, Aug

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

The classic summer combination of sweet strawberries and tart rhubarb topped with a golden pastry lattice.

Available in 9″ only

In Season: Jul, Aug

Apple Crumble pie

Juicy apples with cinnamon and nutmeg baked in a pastry shell,topped with a brown sugar and oatmeal crumble.

In Season: Sep, Oct